Strong Girls--by Ellen Jensen Abbott

The scene I remember the most took place in Rome. Katy Carr has traveled there as the companion of Mrs. Ashe, a widow, and her young daughter Amy. Amy is fighting for her life, a victim of Roman fever. The proprietor of the pension where Katy, Mrs. Ashe and Amy are living threatens to kick them out because word of the fever is hurting her business. Mrs. Ashe is undone by her daughter’s illness so Katy steps forward and argues with the domineering landlord, insisting that the landlord is being inhuman, and that they will not  move—all in her limited French. Standing in the background is the dashing Lt. Ned Worthington, Mrs. Ashe’s brother, and he’s transfixed.  

What’s not to love about this scene from Susan Coolidge’s What Katy Did Next? Katy is powerful and courageous, and the love interest falls for her because of her strength, abandoning his crush on the beautiful but shallow Lily Page for power and passion. It still gives me goose bumps! 

As a writer, I am often asked which books most influenced me. Because I write fantasy, I usually talk about The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, my favorite of the Chronicles of Narnia (all of which I adore). But there is another group of books that influences me perhaps as much. I call them the “strong female character with a hint of romance” books. Think Anne of the Island (the third of the Anne of Green Gables series) or Laura Ingalls Wilder’s These Happy Golden Years or Elizabeth George Speare’s The Witch of Blackbird Pond. Really, any of these books could be featured in this post about first loves, but the one that came to me was Coolidge’s What Katy Did Next, the third of the What Katy Did series. I must have read these books in fourth and fifth grade and I loved Katie Carr, the protagonist. I saw myself in her. She had brown hair (not like all those blonde heroines), had spunk, and became pretty when you got to know her. It felt too self-centered to think of myself as pretty, but I was willing to accept that my personality made me attractive. And it was personality that made Katy, and the other heroines in this group of books, so important to me as a reader. 

I reread this novel in preparation for this post and found Katy as attractive as I remembered her. There is a little moralizing in the novel, moments when the author steps forward to tell her readers what lesson they might take away from a given moment. But the Katy books were written in the 1880s! Modern novelists avoid moralizing like the Roman fever, but as a young reader, I didn’t even notice these few sentences. Like Lt. Worthington, I was transfixed by Katy.


  1. Great post, Ellen! "Strong female character with a hint of romance" books are wonderful. I just finished reading The Secret School by Avi, and it has exactly that. It's a testament to the talent of these authors that they can still inspire, thrill, and move us as adults. I have never read the Katy books but will be sure to check them out!

  2. Love it when the reads of our youth stand the test of time...

  3. Ooooh I haven't heard of these Katy books!

  4. Did Katy have a sister named Clover? And was there a part where Katy was paralyzed or somehow sick, and she was being a pill about it until a relative of theirs (named Helen? or am I confusing her with Helen in Jane Eyre) set a positive example for her?
    If so, I read at least one of these books and also saw a PBS show based on it, and from time to time would think back on it and try to remember, "What WAS the name of that book with Katy and Clover?"

  5. Katy does have a sister named Clover! In fact, I think there is another series about Clover. I hadn't remembered the illness part, but now that you mention it, I think you're right!

  6. What a great post! I never read those books. Will have to check them out!


Post a Comment